Second Chance for a Reformed Liar? Ask The Navidaters!

0
 Dear Navidaters,
Boy, do I have a story for you!  And, of course, I’d love your reaction.  So I married Eli six years ago.  Same old, same old.  We were both very young, very naive, and despite all the resumes, etc., neither of us really knew what we were doing.Eli isn’t a horrible person, but he was a terrible liar.  After we got married, little by little, big and little lies started to surface.  Little things like he really doesn’t enjoy tennis and never wants to play again (I love tennis), to big things like he had no intentions of finishing college.

Image result for he's a liar quotes

I and my entire family are very honest people.  We would never dream of telling a lie or even a white lie for that matter.  We take honesty very seriously.  So you can imagine my horror when I started to learn about all of his bold lies or just twisting his truths to serve his purpose.  His purpose, of course, was to get me to fall in love with him at all costs.  And whatever he felt he had to tell me to make that happen, he told me.  He sold himself really well.

Image result for lies lies lies

 

All this I figured out within the first year of marriage and thankfully, we hadn’t had any children yet, so I decided to get out while the going was good.  I felt I could never remain married to a man who I couldn’t trust at all.  Eli of course was totally not interested in getting divorced, but like I said, he’s not a terrible guy and he didn’t give me a hard time with the “get,” which I was very grateful for.

Anyway, I was dating for a few years and somehow never met anyone who I was excited about.  I forgot to mention that Eli was a lot of fun to be with and was kind and generous.  He really did have some good qualities.  Maybe when I was going out, I was even comparing some of these guys to Eli, which I know must sound a little crazy, since I divorced Eli.  But so it was.

Six months ago I was at a singles event and who do I see walk in the door, but Eli!  I hadn’t seen him in a while and he looked really good.  We kind of avoided one another, but I guess we were both observing each other from the corners of our eyes.  At one point, I think he smiled at me.

eye

 

Eli called me the following week and asked me if I would meet him for coffee.  He said that he had something very important to tell me and had to do it in person.  I was very reluctant to say yes, but at the same time, it wasn’t as if anything too exciting was happening in my dating life, so I agreed to meet him in some far off Starbucks, where I was certain no one would see us.

Image result for i did it

Basically Eli told me that he never stopped loving me and that he understands what he did wrong and has been working on his insecurities that led him to tell me all those lies and that he wants to get back together and spend the rest of his life making it all up to me.  Basically promising me the world.  I think most women would be very tempted by this proposal.  I certainly was.  He looked great, we still had that certain chemistry together and he were able to easily laugh a lot together.  So I must admit that after a little bit of arm twisting, I finally said I would go out with him, but he shouldn’t get his hopes up.

We started dating in far off places.  I was too embarrassed to tell my parents or friends that I was seeing Eli again.  At this point, I knew that they all understandably hated him for causing me so much heartache and pain.  They felt that here I was, a young woman still in her twenties, already with a “been divorced” stamp on me and it was all Eli’s fault.

So here’s my question to you.  I’ve been having a great time going out with Eli.  I’ve started thinking seriously about remarrying him.  I know it sounds crazy.  I don’t know of any stories like mine.  I want to tell my parents, but I know they are going to be furious and scared out of their minds.  If I share this news with my friends, I know they will tell me that I’m looking for trouble and that I should stay clear of Eli, that he’s just selling me on himself again the way he did the first time around.

 

Frankly, I don’t know what to think.  I’m getting older, I want to get married and start a family, and I feel so comfortable with Eli and we really do have a good time together and he’s good to me.  He tells me he’s a changed man and that he doesn’t lie anymore.  But can a person really change in that way?  Can I trust him?

I feel like at this moment I have to either tell everyone that we are dating seriously and take all the criticism that comes my way or break up with Eli.  Of course, I don’t want to do either one.  But Eli’s pressuring me a little and frankly, I’m pressuring myself.

Crazy story – no?  What do you think?

Crazy

Dear Crazy,

I’d rather not call your story “crazy.”  How about interesting?  It certainly isn’t a run of the mill situation.  But I have heard of couples who have gotten divorced, later to remarry and live happily ever after.  It’s not impossible.

not impossible

 

So let’s break it down a bit.  The most important issue here is whether or not Eli is a reformed liar.  Some people like to say that a person never changes their core character traits.  I happen to disagree.  People can be motivated during their lifetime to totally revamp their ways.  It’s not common, it’s not easy and it’s not to be expected.  However, some people have what’s known as “hitting their rock bottom.”  When their life becomes so unmanageable, so disappointing, unfulfilling and so unhappy, that they have to figure out a way to reinvent themselves in order to find a better life.  It can happen.  It takes tremendous perseverance and commitment.  It’s hard work!!

It sounds as though Eli has a number of traits that you find very attractive, so there is definitely much to work with.  However, I agree – without trust, without knowing for sure that you can believe every word that comes out of your spouse’s mouth, is a really a big issue and can definitely undermine any marriage.  Right now you and Eli are having fun.

Image result for having fun

There probably isn’t much reason for Eli to have to lie, since there isn’t much real life pressure on the two of you at the moment.  The question is, how will Eli react when the going gets rough?  If he feels put upon, under the gun, needing once again to impress you?  I’m wondering whether you can take your relationship to a level where Eli has to be accountable for important sharing of information.  Make him uncomfortable and see how he responds.  Do some fact checking.  I’m sure you don’t want to feel like a detective, but a bit of detective work right now, wouldn’t be a bad thing.

Image result for detective work

 

Does Eli have any friends that you feel you can talk to?  Can you talk about whether they have seen a change in him since the divorce?  These are not typical questions to be asking, but your relationship is not typical and requires some extra care.  Take the time to look deeper than what would be normal, ask deeper questions, and don’t be shy about putting your concerns out there.

If Eli passes the test of time and pressure, and you really believe in your heart that he is a changed man, don’t let your parents or friends, who are stuck in their old ideas of who Eli is, prevent you from what might be a wonderful thing.  Validate their concerns, explain your optimism, and encourage them to bring to you anything relevant that they may know about or have heard about Eli that could be a red flag.  Encourage proof (not just rumors). But if they are against the shidduch only on principle, without being able to share any current proof, then that shouldn’t be enough to kill this deal!

Not all of our stories are the same.  And some are way out of the box.  But that fact doesn’t make them hopeless or even less wonderful.

 

The Navidaters

516.224.7779

thenavidaters@gmail.com

Email us with your opinions!  Do you have a question you would like anonymously posted on Simcha Spot?  Email us!  We are working with singles, daters, kallahs and chossons (and parents too!) on all issues concerned with dating and relationships.  Call today to set up your appointment.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments